Skip to main content

Global mineral reserves

We can never extract all of a mineral from the earth but we can extract all of the ore that is easy to extract and end up with progressively less yield. Minerals "run out" when they become so rare and expensive that they can no longer be used in their previous roles.

The amount of a mineral remaining in the ground and the ease of extraction will affect its price and as the price rises other materials will be substituted.  These substituted materials will then also be in danger of running out. Whether the consequences of resource depletion are dire or not depends upon ingenuity of substitution and whether there are serious dislocations as substitution occurs.

The chart below shows the adequacy of current reserves of most commercial minerals.  The adequacy is how long the known reserves will last at current rates of production.

Global mineral reserves. The red line marks 2012

The chart has a logarithmic adequacy scale.  According to this chart Indium should now be in the region where its price will escalate rapidly.  Has this happened?

Historical Indium Prices
it probably has happened, indium is now six times the price in 1994 and the price is very volatile. Indium production, although initially responding to this price rise has stuck at about 600 tonnes per annum. (US Geological Survey). The comment in the US Geological Survey: Mineral Commodity Summaries 2011 is that "Indium’s recent price volatility and various supply concerns associated with the metal have accelerated the development of ITO (Indium Tin Oxide) substitutes. Antimony tin oxide coatings, which are deposited by an ink-jetting process, have been developed as an alternative to ITO ...".

Antimony has a 10-15 year adequacy at current consumption rates - using it as a substitute for indium will reduce this period. So once one rare metal fails there is likely to be increased pressure on substitutes.

In general the price of almost all metals has increased by about 400% since 1994 which suggests that demand is outstripping supply.  The demand is largely in China which takes over half of the world's supply of many metals.  Were the metal ores freely available it would be expected that the global prices would rapidly adjust downwards.

Until 2001 the price of metals fell year on year suggesting increasing availability:

Selected Minerals Prices 1967-2001
Unfortunately it is in the nature of growth curves that everything can be growing apace in one decade then the curve can collapse in the next so the crucial data lies between 2000 and the present day. The curves look rather different for recent years:

The Price of Lead 2000-2009
If the recent price changes are due to shortages rather than a simple excess of demand then there should have been a less than expected increase in the supply of lead as the price increased.  The production of lead did not increase much at all in response to the elevated prices in 2005-2007, US production was particularly refactory:

Lead Production 2000-2009
Something might be going wrong with the ease of production of lead.  We are coming to the end of easily extractable lead but iron ore is abundant.  Iron ore production responded to prices in the expected fashion:

Iron Ore Production and Price 2000-2009

If ore extraction becomes more difficult then more energy is needed in the extraction process.  There is a feedback between oil prices and ore extraction costs. A computer model such as that used in Limits to Growth would be needed to model the complex interactions of energy and metal prices.

The production of zinc, another metal, like lead, that is near to its limits, is also strangely detached from the current price:

Zinc Production and Price 2000-2009
World gold production is also independent of price at about 2500 tonnes a year. However, before accepting that the decoupling of production from price indicates that a mineral is "running out", it should be borne in mind that the production of vanadium was fairly steady at about 50,000 tonnes from 2000-2009 despite large price fluctuations from around $5000 a tonne in 2002 to $38500 a tonne in 2008. Yet there are massive reserves of vanadium. However, vanadium demand has leapt and most pundits blame the price rises on shortages, there being a severe lack of current extraction capacity (reserves) even though there are adequate long term base reserves.  So the failure of vanadium production to respond to demand is an exception that proves the rule that refactory production is indicative of shortage.  In the case of lead and zinc it makes sense for the mining companies to do a complex balancing act, leaving as much as possible in the ground where it can only increase in value whilst producing sufficient to provide healthy profits.

The analysis shows that the adequacy data in the first chart in this article is credible and that lead, tin, zinc, mercury etc. are indeed effectively running out in the coming decade or so.  "Effectively running out" meaning that the price will be high and volatile and production fairly steady or reducing as mining companies start to regard their mines as appreciating assets rather than production facilities.

See also:

The Limits to Growth

Further reading:

Historical statistics for mineral and material commodities in the United States

Scarcity of minerals, metals a concern for manufacturer's suppliers

Mineral reserves are divided into "reserve base", which is all of the mineral currently known to be in the ground and "reserves" which is the part of the base that can be "economically extracted". There is also the "Inferred reserve base" which is a guess at the amount in the ground on the basis of current knowledge.

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

The Falklands have always been Argentine - Las Malvinas son Argentinas

"The Falklands have always been Argentine" is taught to every Argentine child as a matter of faith.  What was Argentina during the time when it "always" possessed Las Malvinas?  In this article I will trace the history of Argentina in the context of its physical and political relationship with "Las Malvinas", the Falkland Islands.  The Argentine claim to the Falkland Islands dates from a brief episode in 1831-32 so it is like Canada claiming the USA despite two centuries of separate development. This might sound like ancient history but Argentina has gone to war for this ancient claim so the following article is well worth reading. For a summary of the legal case see: Las Malvinas: The Legal Case Argentina traces its origins to Spanish South America when it was part of the Viceroyalty of the Rio del Plata.  The Falklands lay off the Viceroyalty of Peru, controlled by the Captain General of Chile.  In 1810 the Falklands were far from the geographical b

Practical Idealism by Richard Nicolaus Coudenhove-Kalergi

Coudenhove-Kalergi was a pioneer of European integration. He was the founder and President for 49 years of the Paneuropean Union. His parents were Heinrich von Coudenhove-Kalergi, an Austro-Hungarian diplomat, and Mitsuko Aoyama, the daughter of an oil merchant, antiques-dealer, and huge landowner family in Tokyo. His "Pan-Europa" was published in 1923 and contained a membership form for the Pan-Europa movement. Coudenhove-Kalergi's movement held its first Congress in Vienna in 1926. In 1927 the French Prime Minister, Aristide Briand was elected honorary president.  Personalities attending included: Albert Einstein, Thomas Mann and Sigmund Freud. Figures who later became central to founding the EU, such as Konrad Adenauer became members . His basic idea was that democracy was a transitional stage that leads to rule by a new aristocracy that is largely taken from the Jewish "master race" (Kalergi's terminology). His movement was reviled by Hitler and H

Membership of the EU: pros and cons

5th December 2013, update May 2016 Nigel Lawson, ex-Chancellor of the Exchequer,  recently criticised the UK membership of the EU , the media has covered his mainstream view as if he is a bad boy starting a fight in the school playground, but is he right about the EU? What has changed that makes EU membership a burning issue?  What has changed is that the 19 countries of the Eurozone are now seeking political union to escape their financial problems.   Seven further EU countries have signed up to join the Euro but the British and Danish have opted out.  The EU is rapidly becoming two blocks - the 26 and Britain and Denmark.   Lawson's fear was that if Britain stays in the EU it will be isolated and dominated by a Eurozone bloc that uses "unified representation of the euro area" , so acting like a single country which controls 90% of the vote in the EU with no vetoes available to the UK in most decisions.  The full plans for Eurozone political union ( EMU Stage